Interesting argument. I have to side with "guest" on this one - triode operation of a pentode does tie the screen grid to the plate.
Tubeman... you have your grid numbers and connections mixed up also. I'm sure you know this, but for those that don't, it is tradition to number the grids in this manner, which reflects the history of grid evolution:
Grid #1 is the control grid,
Grid #2 is the screen grid,
Grid #3 is the suppressor grid.
In some tubes, such as the 6550, there is no choice as to where to tie the supressor (grid #3) as it is internally connected to the cathode. Other tubes, such as the EL34, do give you this option.