Does this cabinet design need speaker damping material? It doesn't have any and I don't think it ever did. Thanks everybody about your input on speakers.
Both of mine, and every other 215S I've seen
have damping. As a rule of thumb, pretty much EVERY cab; particularly a bass reflex cab, will benefit sonically from damping material.
As far as I can ascertain, there are no more factory D or K series JBL recone kits anymore, and E's are getting really expensive.
IMO the OEM factory cones are
extremely important to the "AlNiCo JBL sound"; after all, the
only difference between a D130, D130F, D140F, K130, and K140
is the cone assembly. The motors are the same, however anyone who has experience with comparing those models know that there is unquestionably a difference between the drivers in response characteristics and tonally.
And... that difference is all in the cones. I would say that replacing the cone in a D or K series with a generic recone kit is a crap shoot; it may sound great, may sound like ass, but what it probably
won't sound like is a factory D or K series.
I have some D's with factory E recone kits. To my ear they don't sound like D's
or E's, however luckily (to me) they
do sound like K's which are my overall favorite, so I got lucky.
I've gigged D140's, K140's, Altec 421's, EVM15L's, EVM15B's, EV SRO's and Reeves proprietary designed speakers in my 215S's.
None of them sound
bad; in fact they all sound pretty good in the versatile 215S cab, but each have their differences and are best suited to certain specific applications. I keep EVM15L's loaded in one because I think they sound the best with the Reeves C225 that I usually use it with. The C225 has insanely huge bottom end and the higher voiced L's seem to match up well with that big bottom to produce a very articulate mid-high response, combined with a real defined tight bottom end, less sloppy and boomy than the B's, and better at handling the power than the JBL's or the Altecs. I keep my "pseudo K's"; D's with E cones, in the other one because I generally use it with a 2000S and to my ears a 2000S through K's is pretty much tonal nirvana.